Unaffiliated · nontheistic

Spiritual But Not Religious

Something more than the material, approached personally and eclectically, with institutions declined on principle. This is a described population rather than a doctrine, which is why its dispersions are the widest in the matrix after Unitarian Universalism.

What makes it unusual

The axes on which this religion sits furthest from the middle of the matrix — which is to say, the positions that actually distinguish it.

  • B3 Institutional authorityindividual conscience decidesFurther toward "individual conscience decides" than most traditions in the matrix.
  • E3 Locus of belongingan individual choiceFurther toward "an individual choice" than most traditions in the matrix.
  • B1 Source of truthreason and direct experienceFurther toward "reason and direct experience" than most traditions in the matrix.
  • E1 Exclusivitymany valid pathsFurther toward "many valid paths" than most traditions in the matrix.

All seventeen positions

Each cell carries a centre, a dispersion — how much internal variation the religion genuinely tolerates — and the source the position rests on. Disagree with one? Say so; corrections are public and recorded.

The same seventeen values as a single shape, read clockwise from A1 at the top. The outline is where the religion sits; the wider band around it is the variation it genuinely tolerates, so a tight outline is a tight religion.

  • position
  • tolerated variation

A · The divine

AxisPositionValue±σ
A1 Divine realitynothing beyond the natural → a divine reality certainly existsleaning a divine reality certainly existsSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.700.22
A2 Personhoodimpersonal principle or order → a personal being one can addressbetween impersonal principle or order and a personal being one can addressSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.380.24
A3 Pluralitystrictly one → many powers and spiritsbetween strictly one and many powers and spiritsSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.480.22
A4 Locuswholly beyond the world → fully present within itleaning fully present within itSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.820.13

B · Knowledge and authority

AxisPositionValue±σ
B1 Source of truthrevealed and fixed → reason and direct experiencereason and direct experienceSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.920.06
B2 Reading of sacred textliteral and binding → metaphorical, or no text at allmetaphorical, or no text at allSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.900.08
B3 Institutional authorityclergy and tradition decide → individual conscience decidesindividual conscience decidesSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.950.04

C · Self and destiny

AxisPositionValue±σ
C1 Survival of the selfends at death → continues in some formleaning continues in some formSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.680.22
C2 Shape of timeone life, then judgment → cyclical returnbetween one life, then judgment and cyclical returnSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.580.24
C3 The human conditionfallen and in need of rescue → ignorant but fundamentally soundignorant but fundamentally soundSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.880.08

D · Practice

AxisPositionValue±σ
D1 Mechanism of the ultimate goodgiven as grace → achieved by effort or insightleaning achieved by effort or insightSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.780.14
D2 Centrality of ritualessential and prescribed → optional or absentleaning optional or absentSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.680.18
D3 The bodyto be disciplined → to be celebratedleaning to be celebratedSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.780.12

E · World and others

AxisPositionValue±σ
E1 Exclusivityone true path → many valid pathsmany valid pathsSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.950.04
E2 Origin of the cosmosan intentional act → beginningless or naturalbetween an intentional act and beginningless or naturalSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.580.24
E3 Locus of belonginga people, inherited → an individual choicean individual choiceSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.950.03
E4 Standing of naturecreation, given for use → animate and itself sacredleaning animate and itself sacredSurvey scholarship on the spiritual-but-not-religious (Pew, Fuller, Mercadante)0.820.12

Further reading

Compared with

Where do you sit?

The questionnaire places your own answers on these same seventeen axes and reports how close you are to this religion and to 64 others. Take it — eight to fourteen questions, nothing transmitted.