Across families
Philosophical Naturalism and Twelver Shia Islam
Different families with 3 axes in close agreement — the sort of pairing a quiz weighting only the divine axes would never surface. Mean distance across all seventeen axes: 0.57 (0 would be identical).
The claim that the natural world is all there is, argued as a position rather than assumed as a mood. Less interested than humanism in supplying a replacement ethics, and correspondingly less pluralist about what counts as true.
Shares Sunni tawhid and adds a line of divinely appointed Imams, a living scholarly authority one formally follows, and a devotional life built around lament and intercession. Authority sits markedly more centrally than in Sunni practice.
Where they agree
C2 Shape of time
Both sit at one life, then judgment — a gap of 0.03.
E4 Standing of nature
Both sit at between creation, given for use and animate and itself sacred — a gap of 0.04.
A3 Plurality
Both sit at strictly one — a gap of 0.11.
Where they part company
A1 Divine reality
Philosophical Naturalism: nothing beyond the natural. Twelver Shia Islam: a divine reality certainly exists. A gap of 0.99 on an axis running from “nothing beyond the natural” to “a divine reality certainly exists”.
C1 Survival of the self
Philosophical Naturalism: ends at death. Twelver Shia Islam: continues in some form. A gap of 0.96 on an axis running from “ends at death” to “continues in some form”.
E2 Origin of the cosmos
Philosophical Naturalism: beginningless or natural. Twelver Shia Islam: an intentional act. A gap of 0.96 on an axis running from “an intentional act” to “beginningless or natural”.
D2 Centrality of ritual
Philosophical Naturalism: optional or absent. Twelver Shia Islam: essential and prescribed. A gap of 0.92 on an axis running from “essential and prescribed” to “optional or absent”.
A2 Personhood
Philosophical Naturalism: impersonal principle or order. Twelver Shia Islam: a personal being one can address. A gap of 0.91 on an axis running from “impersonal principle or order” to “a personal being one can address”.
B1 Source of truth
Philosophical Naturalism: reason and direct experience. Twelver Shia Islam: leaning revealed and fixed. A gap of 0.78 on an axis running from “revealed and fixed” to “reason and direct experience”.
B2 Reading of sacred text
Philosophical Naturalism: metaphorical, or no text at all. Twelver Shia Islam: leaning literal and binding. A gap of 0.77 on an axis running from “literal and binding” to “metaphorical, or no text at all”.
B3 Institutional authority
Philosophical Naturalism: individual conscience decides. Twelver Shia Islam: clergy and tradition decide. A gap of 0.77 on an axis running from “clergy and tradition decide” to “individual conscience decides”.
E3 Locus of belonging
Philosophical Naturalism: an individual choice. Twelver Shia Islam: leaning a people, inherited. A gap of 0.62 on an axis running from “a people, inherited” to “an individual choice”.
E1 Exclusivity
Philosophical Naturalism: between one true path and many valid paths. Twelver Shia Islam: one true path. A gap of 0.47 on an axis running from “one true path” to “many valid paths”.
D1 Mechanism of the ultimate good
Philosophical Naturalism: achieved by effort or insight. Twelver Shia Islam: between given as grace and achieved by effort or insight. A gap of 0.44 on an axis running from “given as grace” to “achieved by effort or insight”.
All seventeen axes
| Axis | Philosophical Naturalism | Twelver Shia Islam | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| A1 Divine reality | nothing beyond the natural | a divine reality certainly exists | 0.99 |
| A2 Personhood | impersonal principle or order | a personal being one can address | 0.91 |
| A3 Plurality | strictly one | strictly one | 0.11 |
| A4 Locus | wholly beyond the world | leaning wholly beyond the world | 0.24 |
| B1 Source of truth | reason and direct experience | leaning revealed and fixed | 0.78 |
| B2 Reading of sacred text | metaphorical, or no text at all | leaning literal and binding | 0.77 |
| B3 Institutional authority | individual conscience decides | clergy and tradition decide | 0.77 |
| C1 Survival of the self | ends at death | continues in some form | 0.96 |
| C2 Shape of time | one life, then judgment | one life, then judgment | 0.03 |
| C3 The human condition | leaning ignorant but fundamentally sound | between fallen and in need of rescue and ignorant but fundamentally sound | 0.23 |
| D1 Mechanism of the ultimate good | achieved by effort or insight | between given as grace and achieved by effort or insight | 0.44 |
| D2 Centrality of ritual | optional or absent | essential and prescribed | 0.92 |
| D3 The body | leaning to be celebrated | leaning to be disciplined | 0.38 |
| E1 Exclusivity | between one true path and many valid paths | one true path | 0.47 |
| E2 Origin of the cosmos | beginningless or natural | an intentional act | 0.96 |
| E3 Locus of belonging | an individual choice | leaning a people, inherited | 0.62 |
| E4 Standing of nature | between creation, given for use and animate and itself sacred | between creation, given for use and animate and itself sacred | 0.04 |
Positions for Philosophical Naturalism rest principally on Contemporary philosophical naturalism (Dennett, Sellars, Papineau); for Twelver Shia Islam, on Nahj al-Balagha, al-Kafi, and Twelver usul al-din. Per-cell sources are listed on each religion’s own page.
The questionnaire places your answers on these same axes and ranks all 65 religions and worldviews by how closely they match. Take it.